Cap'n signed on for making the last few phone calls to various butcher shops. Never once did he hear that they just don't exist/can't order them that I heard twice, so perhaps it pays to sound manly when calling butcher shops. Our starting point was a week's lead time and $220 for a pig somewhere less than 49 pounds, and hopefully somewhere in the range we were actually looking for--the 18-24 lb size.
A very friendly locally owned grocery store told us that he didn't like being the middle-man in these transactions; they had to mark them up a lot and his source didn't mind if we called. So we called Mohammed at Select Gourmet Foods and he totally hooked us up. Mr. Dignified Pig should be close to 20 lbs--no less than 18, no more than 25, and be a flat rate of $175.
We also settled on a fancy grill I call an outdoor oven to cook him in. Digging a pit (there was a backhoe available, briefly) sounded cool, but it also sounded the trickiest, because your basically build an underground oven, fill it to a proper height with hot coals, insert the thing to be cooked, wrap it in more coals, and continue to refresh the hot coals during the time it takes to cook. So, some constantly-running fire pit is needed in addition to the pit oven. Not for this group.
The method that sounds most appealing takes gear we're not ready to invest in. Among the four couples signed on for the Pig Project, there are two solid-quality outdoor grills. There is one backyard. There are three infants. This is not the time to shell out a grand for a cast iron spit roasting kit. But I do still have the directions, and it can't be that hard to find a blacksmith, between my geek connections (think chainmail) and my farm connections (think back-to-the-earth DIY folks with mad skillz). So spit roasting will happen someday. I would love to try it with goat.
In the meantime, we have the pig source, the date, the cooking method and are lining up a few side dishes. I read a suggestion of placing a pan filled with sauerkraut under Mr. Pig as he cooks, so it gets all porky-delicous. I plan on doing lots of cross-hatching of the skin and hitting it with lots of fresh thyme, black pepper and kosher salt. Tinfoil earmuffs to prevent burning; occasional basting with butter to get a really crisp skin. I am looking forward to this, I must say.